Understanding BMI: The Good, The Bad, and What's Next

If you've ever had a checkup, you've probably encountered the term "BMI" somewhere in your medical record. BMI, short for body mass index, is a simple measure that uses your height and weight to estimate body fat. However, despite its widespread use, BMI has become a controversial topic, and for good reason. Critics argue that it often paints an inaccurate picture of individual health. So, why is BMI still being used? Let’s explore its problems, why it persists, and what might replace it in the future.

The Origins of BMI

BMI was invented in the 1830s by Belgian mathematician Adolphe Quetelet, who had no intention of creating a health metric. Quetelet’s work was focused on the "ideal" human body, specifically among white European men, leading to a calculation called the Quetelet Index—simply your weight divided by your height squared.

The concept gathered dust for over a century until the 1970s when American physiologist Ancel Keys revived and renamed it "Body Mass Index" (BMI). Keys found that BMI could be a useful tool to study obesity on a population level. It was simple, cost-effective, and—while not perfect—helped correlate weight to potential health risks. BMI wasn’t widely used in healthcare until the 1990s, when it became a standard tool to screen for obesity during routine medical visits.

The Problems with BMI

Though BMI has been used for decades, its flaws have become more evident over time. Here are the three major issues:

1. BMI Doesn’t Measure What It’s Supposed To
   BMI is not a direct measure of body fat. It also doesn’t differentiate between muscle and fat, which means that someone with a high amount of muscle mass, like an athlete, could be classified as obese. On the flip side, a person with a "normal" BMI might still have a high percentage of visceral fat—the type strongly linked to serious health risks like type 2 diabetes and heart disease.

2. BMI Lacks Inclusivity
   BMI was originally developed based on data from healthy white men. This lack of inclusivity means that the BMI scale may not accurately reflect health risks for people of different ethnicities or body types. For example, studies have shown that individuals of Asian descent may develop obesity-related health issues at a lower BMI than people of European descent, making the standard BMI cutoff of 30 problematic for them.

3. BMI Can Increase Weight Bias
   BMI can sometimes lead to weight bias in healthcare. Overweight patients often report feeling judged during medical visits, where their weight is brought up even if it’s irrelevant to the health issue they’re addressing. This can lead to missed diagnoses, delayed treatment, and even a reluctance to seek care.

Why Do We Still Use BMI?

Despite its flaws, BMI remains widely used because it’s a convenient screening tool for population health. It's easy to calculate, inexpensive, and non-invasive. BMI can still help doctors identify trends in obesity and its related risks in large populations, even if it falls short on an individual level.

What’s Next? The Future of Measuring Health Risks

While BMI is still prevalent, there are other tools available that may eventually replace it, especially when looking at individual health:

• Body Fat Calipers: These measure fat in specific areas of the body, though their accuracy varies.
• DEXA Scans: A more precise way to measure body composition, but they are expensive and involve exposure to low levels of radiation.
• Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA): Found in many body composition scales, BIA uses electrical currents to estimate fat and muscle percentages. Some predict BIA may eventually become the standard, but its accuracy is still debated.

AI could also play a future role in refining how we assess obesity risk, offering a more personalized approach by analyzing millions of data points to create a more inclusive health metric.

The Bottom Line

BMI is an imperfect tool, but for now, it’s the one we’ve got. The key is understanding its limitations and using it alongside other health data to get a fuller picture of a person’s well-being. Just like any tool, it can be misused, but with proper application, it still serves a purpose in identifying potential health risks.

At Brooktree Consulting, we take a more comprehensive approach to health and wellness. Instead of relying solely on BMI, we evaluate a variety of factors like body composition, lifestyle habits, and personal health history to craft individualized plans. If you're ready to take a more holistic approach to your health, contact us today for a discovery call. Let’s work together to build a healthier, happier future for you.

Interested in learning more about your own health journey? Schedule a discovery call with me, Kurt, at Brooktree Consulting today and discover how we can help you achieve your wellness goals.
Sign up for this short video tutorial to learn more about my proven 4-phase process and take the first step toward a healthier lifestyle.